How to critique an academic article. Finding an Article Critique Example 2018-12-24

How to critique an academic article Rating: 4,5/10 259 reviews

Scholarly Article Critique Student Example

how to critique an academic article

Once you have done this, you should then move to preparing your evidence and arguments cogently and vividly. There may also be recommendations for further research. Next, rewrite the article in your own words, either in a long paragraph or as an outline. . Determine how the article you are reviewing is similar and different from other texts you've read on the subject.

Next

How to Critique a Research Article

how to critique an academic article

Record your initial reactions to the text. Step Four: Write out your major criticisms of the article. Approach B Another common way to structure a journal article critique is the following: Introduction In the introduction, cite the journal article in full and provide a summary of the journal article. It is often a difficult-to-read article, which requires repeated reading, and taking of notes. Writing an article critique is an in-depth analysis of the article, evaluating its success in conveying the objective of the article. If you are facing these dilemmas, there is no need to panic. Bioscience 41 4 , 248-250.


Next

Writing for an academic journal: 10 tips

how to critique an academic article

In-text citations should be made using the author-date system, which means that you only need to indicate name of the author, followed by the year of publication. Note relevant facts and findings of the article. Respond only to the author's research; do not provide any new research. Literary criticism estimates the main contemporary trends of the literary development; it interprets the works of art from the perspective of the present. Take a standpoint of either supporting or not with the author's assertions but support your arguments with facts and relevant theories that are pertinent to the area of knowledge. An Article Review is a critical, constructive evaluation of literature in a particular field through summary, classification, analysis, and comparison.

Next

How To Critique An Article: Helpfun Article Critique Writing Tips

how to critique an academic article

The site make things easy. Thus you might consider dividing your outline according to these sections as well as subheadings within the body. However, main argument is an essential part of your work and you need to include it at the beginning of your paper to make sure everyone knows what your position on the subject is. It is sometimes helpful to use a red pen to make your markings stand out. Junior high coaches were significantly lower in training and instruction than either high school or college coaches.


Next

Article Critique Writing Service

how to critique an academic article

Developing unique symbols that will help you understand your markups. Search through the Article to Check for Biases In case the author has something to profit from the various conclusions and points that are depicted in the piece, then there is a possibility of bias being demonstrated. Ren, Q, and X Gong, 2012, Evaluation index system for academic papers of humanities and social sciences, Scientometrics 93, 1047—1060. You as a reviewer are part of the process. Review articles summarize and evaluate current studies research articles on a particular topic.

Next

How to Critique a Research Article

how to critique an academic article

If you follow all the recommendations, you will easily complete an outstanding article critique without any efforts! Can one observe it from all possible angles? We may want a generalist, a subject specialist, someone with experience in the methodology and someone whose work is being critiqued. Materials and Methods Similar to a recipe, the description of materials and methods will allow others to replicate the study elsewhere if needed. Are there any troubles caused by the language of the article? Then put all the paragraphs together and devise an insightful article review. When you agree to review a paper with a timeline given, unless there is a really good reason, you should stick to it. Does the text complement, and not simple repeat, data? At other times the barrier is harder, or even impossible to cross.

Next

Scholarly Article Critique Student Example

how to critique an academic article

Year, Month Date of Publication. This comes in handy if you want to focus the review towards the content of a course. The term article review is not always clear to students who are given this assignment. If the program has had several losing seasons in a row, perhaps the attitude of the coach could be different than that of a coach who has recently won a state title. If critiquing an article containing a scientific theory, be sure to evaluate the research methods behind the experiment. If you know how to write an article critique, you will easily complete the assignment not depending on its complexity and formatting peculiarities.

Next

Scholarly Article Critique Student Example

how to critique an academic article

If you find yourself troubled with the prewriting and the brainstorming process for this assignment, seek out a sample article review outline. Your evidence will go in the body paragraphs of your critique. Rather, try to identify the various strengths and weaknesses in the piece under review. Develop a preliminary concept for your critique. Understanding the main points and arguments of the article is essential for an accurate summation.

Next

How to Critique a Research Article

how to critique an academic article

So, don't feel bad about rejecting an invite, be positive and use the process to suggest others. If it is a scientific review article, it uses database searches to portray the research. Don't: spend time on editing or phrasing. However, if you are correcting misleading or otherwise incorrect points, some new data may be presented. What kind of data can be obtained using each technique? Usually, when students are given an assignment they try this technical gift of copy pasting everything, but for a media student I feel this won't work. The results indicated no significant interactions.

Next